IdStory IdM modules » Registration (reg)

This is not defect. You either need to specify login generator and mark username eav as read-only (which will result in this attribute not showing in registration form), or you let user choose their username by letting them fill it in the form. But you always must specify username somehow.

I doesn't agree, some default behavior should be defined and application should work as default. The same as #1400.

Default behavior after module instalation is username showing in registration form. If you delete the required attribute from configuration and then complain that it does not work, then i cant really do much.

Use cases:

1) username is generated by default generators in Reg module. Username does not have to be defined in EAV. It is useless attribute that will be show in eavs.
2) username is generated by generators in core module. Username does not have to be defined in EAV. It is also useless attribute that will be show in eavs.

Some existing project that use reg module doesn't defined username in eaves. The project/s is still not upgradable to newer version.

Now exists bigger problem defined in #1449 this ticket is minor problem that can be solved by override service DefaultRegIdentityService. But the method in ticket #1449 can search attributes in different formDefinition.